property

French couple get house sale annulled over noisy neighbour

Buyers fought 12-year legal battle over property

,The case was ultimately taken to France's highest court, the Cour de Cassation
Published

A noisy neighbour is many homebuyers’ worst nightmare. However, one couple suffered more than most, mounting a 12-year legal battle with the person who sold them their house in a bid to get their money back because of the noise from next door.

The couple bought their house in Courbevoie, a suburb of Paris in Hauts-de-Seine, in 2013.

They were drawn to the 211m² property by its garden, which they thought would be ideal for their young children.

Soon after moving in, however, the family realised the house was not the quiet space they had imagined.

The property was located next to a greengrocer, which caused significant noise disturbance, including from deliveries and equipment such as a hydraulic freight lift and pallet trucks.

The couple decided to take legal action, arguing that the noise was severely affecting their quality of life. Their aim was to have the sale annulled on the grounds of a "mistake regarding the substantial qualities of the property."

An expert appointed by the court found there was an "abnormal neighbourhood disturbance”, and referenced a 1963 law which limits permissible noise levels above ambient background noise to +5 decibels during the day and +3 decibels at night.

The equipment used by the greengrocer was producing noise levels ranging from +15 to +36 decibels above ambient noise.

Court win on appeal

Despite the proven noise pollution, Nanterre Judicial Court dismissed the buyers’ claims in 2020, but the couple appealed the ruling and won their case at the Versailles Court of Appeal in July 2023.

The seller was ordered to return the €1.18million the couple paid for the house, and pay nearly €94,000 for costs associated with the sale.

The greengrocer and seller were also held jointly liable to pay €100,000 to compensate the buyers for the loss of opportunity to realise a capital gain on the house. And the greengrocer was ordered to pay €10,000 in damages.

The appeal judges found that the seller was aware of the issue and that his "culpable omission contributed to the buyers' fundamental error." House viewings prior to the sale had been scheduled for the quietest times.

Amended ruling

The seller and neighbouring business appealed the decision at France’s highest court, the Cour de Cassation. 

While the court did not overturn the annulment of the sale in its ruling in January 2026, it did overturn the €100,000 to be paid to the buyers for lost opportunity to release a capital gain.

The buyers could not benefit from both the sale’s annulment and claim compensation for a lost opportunity, it said.

It also overturned the reimbursement of the €94,000 in transaction costs, ruling that the seller should only have to repay sums he personally received, which did not include the notaire/transaction fees, and a further €35,808 awarded for home improvement works the buyers had carried out.

French law can be strict when it comes to noise pollution. Residents are subject to specific hours when they can complete noisy tasks such as mowing their lawns, and one town recently issued a bylaw to fine owners of dogs that barked at night.