property
Is it worthwhile investing in a Paris pied-à-terre?
The legal restrictions, tax obligations and building rules to consider before buying a second home in the French capital
Those thinking of buying a second home in Paris to enjoy for themselves and to use as a rental should be aware of the strict French rules they need to keep in mind.
Short-term holiday rentals in France are highly regulated, and owning a second home does not mean you automatically have the right to list it on Airbnb whenever you are away.
Raphaël Dardek, CEO of Guava Partners, a buyer-side property advisory, said he had been receiving a lot of interest from Americans looking to purchase a second home in Paris, otherwise known as a pied-à-terre.
"Some of my clients still want to live in Paris and have a pied-à-terre, but they would also like to rent it out when they are not here," he told The Connexion.
Can you rent out a Paris second home?
In Paris, owners can rent out their primary residence as furnished tourist accommodation for up to 90 days per year, but this rule does not give owners of second homes the same right.
Anyone wishing to rent out a property that is not their primary residence for short-term stays must first obtain an authorisation for change of use to a furnished tourist rental (autorisation de changement d'usage pour location en meublé de tourisme).
This requires permission from the City of Paris and involves a compensation requirement.
This means that owners must convert non-residential premises, such as an office or a shop, into housing to make up for the loss of residential accommodation.
Owners must also obtain planning permission to change the property's designation to hotel accommodation (hébergement hôtelier). This too is done through the City of Paris.
When both authorisations are granted, the owner must complete a separate online registration procedure and obtain a registration number, which must be included in rental listings. Visitor tax must also be paid on rental stays.
"It's almost impossible to rent an apartment in Paris for a short stay if it's your secondary home," Mr Dardek said.
"Some people are doing it in a grey area. They rent to friends or acquaintances, even if they find them through Facebook. But this is not legal, and if you get caught by the authorities, you can pay a big fine."
Recently, a Paris landlord was ordered to pay €110,000 for illegally renting out an apartment on Airbnb. This included a €100,000 penalty and a €10,000 fine for not providing rental records the city had demanded.
A similar sentence was given to a Marseille landlord in July.
Alternatives to short-term holiday lets
One possibility for owners who want to retain access to their property is to rent it out for longer periods instead of offering nightly or weekly stays.
Dardek explained that there are different types of rental contracts in France: unfurnished leases, furnished leases and civil-law leases (baux civils).
A standard unfurnished lease lasts three years, while a furnished residential lease usually lasts one year.
A more interesting option, though, is a bail mobilité, which can be more flexible as it lasts between one and 10 months.
However, it is only available to tenants in certain circumstances, such as students, people in professional training and employees on temporary assignments.
Another option is a civil-law lease, which is commonly used for second homes and can offer greater flexibility for owners who want to use their property themselves for part of the year.
"For example, if you want to use the property for six months in a year, you can rent it for the other six months with this kind of lease."
Rules, however, vary outside Paris. Some nearby communes, including Levallois-Perret, Clichy and Saint-Ouen, have less restrictive short-term rental arrangements, so buyers are encouraged to check the municipality's regulations before committing.
What taxes should you expect?
Income from renting out furnished accommodation is taxed in France as business income (bénéfices industriels et commerciaux, or BIC). Micro-BIC is only available up to €15,000 income.
For an unclassified furnished tourist rental, the simplified micro-BIC tax regime gives owners a flat 30% allowance for expenses. This means 70% of the rental income is counted when calculating income tax, while social charges apply.
Owners using the actual-expenses regime can instead deduct eligible costs, with tax calculated on the profit left after these expenses.
American owners in particular should also check their US tax reporting obligations and how the France-US tax treaty applies to them.
These are costs to consider alongside the annual property tax (taxe foncière) and the tax on second homes (taxe d'habitation). Buyers should also take into account maintenance, insurance and building charges.
Check the building rules before buying
Another consideration for buyers is the building's co-ownership regulations (règlement de copropriété), said Mr Dardek.
Even if a property meets the municipal requirements, its building rules may restrict or prohibit furnished tourist rentals.
"You have to review the by-laws before buying the property, because sometimes furnished tourist rentals are allowed by the co-ownership regulations," Mr Dardek said.
Buyers should also examine the minutes of previous co-ownership meetings, which can reveal hidden costs.
"For example, you buy an apartment in Paris and you didn't see that there is a roof renovation coming next year."
He explained that a reference to a leak in the roof might appear in just one line among dozens of pages of meeting minutes.
"If you miss that information, it can cost you €10,000 to €50,000, depending on the building."
Finally, the property's energy performance rating (diagnostic de performance énergétique, or DPE) is another important check.
For a new change-of-use authorisation for a furnished tourist rental in mainland France, the property must currently have an energy rating between A and E. Properties rated F or G cannot obtain this authorisation without first improving their energy performance.
Is it still worth buying?
"Even after paying taxes and the fees charged by short-term rental platforms, if you have a nice apartment in Paris or next to Paris, it is always something very interesting," said Mr Dardek.
He said there was strong demand for good-quality accommodation in Paris and its surrounding suburbs, while the city's hotel capacity was not sufficient to accommodate all visitors.
"So yes, I think it is worth it."