letters

Why throwing fish matters in France

Dunkirk’s celebration of the humble herring creates community cohesion, says reader

Fresh Atlantic herring lie in overlapping rows on a cutting board.
Catch of the day or symbol of collectivity?
Published Modified

To the Editor,

There is something wonderfully improbable about standing in a crowd outside Dunkirk’s town hall and hoping someone throws you a smoked herring.

Yet that is precisely the point. During Carnival, the herring tossed from the Hôtel de Ville balcony stops being an ordinary fish. People reach for it, laugh over it, take it home, and remember where they were when they caught it. A cheap and familiar object becomes a souvenir of belonging.

Anthropologists have often been interested in moments like this. Franz Boas, writing about the peoples of the north-west coast of North America, described ceremonies in which giving was public and carried meanings far beyond the value of the objects exchanged. I do not mean to suggest that Dunkirk’s Carnival descends from the potlatch, or that the two customs are historically connected. They plainly are not.

But the comparison does suggest why throwing fish can matter.

A community does not live by official history alone. It also lives through jokes, repeated gestures, familiar foods and things people do simply because their parents and grandparents did them before.

That is what I find so appealing about Dunkirk’s herring. The custom is funny without being trivial. For a moment, the whole city participates in the same ridiculous ritual, and an ordinary fish becomes proof that you were part of it.

C.L., by email

Have you had a similar experience? Write to us at letters@connexionfrance.com